New Zealand Finance Minister Grant Robertson now requires the Reserve Bank (RBNZ) to consider the impact its monetary policy decisions have on house prices, following a revision to RBNZ’s remit.
While the government’s Monetary Policy Committee’s main objectives remain unchanged (targeting inflation and employment), the revised remit will increase focus and understanding on the Banks OCR decisions and the impact on house price sustainability.
The rational is simple – record low interest rates have bolstered demand for housing and credit, pushing house prices to astronomical levels. This has called into question the government’s stated commitment to improving housing affordability for all New Zealanders.
The revised remit stipulates the Government’s policy is to “support more sustainable house prices, including by dampening investor demand for existing housing stock, which would improve affordability for first-home buyers”.
Robertson said the Committee can decide how its decisions take account of housing consequences, but it will need to explain regularly how it has sought to assess their impacts. The new remit takes effect from 1 March.
The Monetary Policy Committee has stressed “prolonged monetary stimulus” (low interest rates) is necessary to protect employment and promote economic expansion following the economic shock caused by COVID-19. It said it would maintain current policy until it was confident inflation is “sustained” at 2% per year, and employment is “at or above” its maximum sustainable level.
In this regard, we do not expect the revised remit to impact OCR decisions. In fact, the RBNZ openly opposed the New Zealand’s Governments initial proposal late last year to require it to consider house prices when setting monetary policy, arguing it would rather be made to consider house prices through the way it regulates banks (through macro-prudential tools such as ‘loan-to-value ratios’ and ‘debt-to-income ratios’).
Despite such opposition, the new directive has been issued to the RBNZ (under section 68B of the Reserve Bank Act). In a statement from RBNZ Governor Adrian Orr, the Governor reinforced his previous comments, saying that the RBNZ’s actions are among “many” that influence house prices.
Finance Minister Grant Robertson did however ask the RBNZ to provide advice on restricting borrowers’ debt-to-income ratios and interest only mortgages.
“I want to understand the extent to which interest-only mortgages (particularly to speculators) pose risks to financial stability, and whether restrictions should apply,” he said, adding that jurisdictions such as Australia have in the past applied restrictions on interest-only mortgages due to financial stability risks.
He said he had already made clear in principle that he would want these to apply only to investors. “”It’s important that any potential restrictions do not disproportionately affect first-home buyers and low-income borrowers,” said the finance minister.
Orr had earlier told the media that he did not share Robertson’s view. Orr said: “It is incredibly difficult to segment any market and any individual with macro-prudential tools. The phrase “macro” means it’s the same tool for all. So, pretending we could fine tune for a particular set or groups comes with great challenge and implications.”
The RBNZ has already applied more onerous loan-to-value ratio (LVR) restrictions on residential property investors than it has on owner-occupiers, requiring them to have larger deposits when taking out mortgages.
Should the Government agree with the RBNZ’s recommendations, then it would not be surprising to see debt-to-income ratios and restrictions on interest only loan implemented in 2021. While such measures may take some heat out of the market, the single most important factor driving current market conditions remains unchanged – interest rates.
Want to know more? Talk to one of our experienced, business-minded lending managers today, we can help you get your project off the ground.